Stealth Fiction

Candy Hearts

A stuttering boy offers Lacie Trevens a box of candy hearts outside the classroom, and she eats every one of them without noticing three of the messages.

  • 327 reach (total reach)
  • 5 Feb 20155 Feb ’15 (first posted)
  • 13 Nov 202613 Nov ’26 (last edit)
  • 279 words (length)
  • Audio 2:18 (audiobook narration)

Read Candy Hearts

Candy Hearts2 min read
Text size
100%
Theme
Typeface and spacing
Full screen

Waiting outside the classroom, the Valentine’s Day gift weighed heavily in my sweaty palm. Across the hall, Lacie Trevens stood at her locker, laughing with her prep friends. She kissed the jock, then turned to enter the classroom.

I called out, “Lacie, wi-wi-will you be my Va-va-valentine?”

Lacie stepped back, blocking the classroom door. Kids began to crowd behind her as she sneered at the picture of Cupid on the small box. “Even if I didn’t have a boyfriend, I wouldn’t date you. Ewww.”

All the kids in the hallway laughed.

Remembering that I’d loved her since first grade, I whispered, “Please open it,” and thrust the gift into her hand.

Lacie flipped open the lid and shook out two pink, heart-shaped candies into her palm. “Be Mine? Kiss Me? We’re not in elementary school, retard.”

The kids laughed again, and Lacie popped the candies into her mouth, chewed them, then reached for another. “Miss You?” As the bell rang, she swallowed that one, too. “Now move, creep.”

Tears welling, I stepped back. Lacie and the class walked past, laughing, rolling their eyes, and calling me dirty names. I’d expected mocking—it happened all the time.

Once they’d all taken their seats, I crawled into my chair behind Lacie and watched her grab candy after candy, mindlessly chewing, unaware of the tiny messages. Candy hearts had always disturbed me. How easily they’re crushed and eaten… How unlike a real heart.

Real hearts are tough.

Before class ended, Lacie had finished ingesting all my love. She hadn’t noticed the three special candies. Rat poison is easily masked.

Smiling, I mouthed the message of the three she’d eaten: “Die.” “Bitch.” “Die.”

The end

Listen

Audio versions: podcasts, audio dramas and YouTube narrations
ElevenLabs NarrationRead by Jane Doe, a digital voice
14 Nov 2026 · 2 min
MP3 5.3 MBAudiobook 3.6 MB

Notes

From the author

Just a little idea. I wrote it for the Valentine's Day contest on r/shortscarystories: a boy who stutters, the girl he's loved since first grade, and a small box with Cupid on the lid. Everything hangs on the tiny messages printed on the candy, Be Mine? and Kiss Me?, and on whether anybody bothers to read them.

Back then I had to explain the ending in the comments. This edition says it outright.

The pictures are all candy-heart pastels and comic-strip kids, so the page looks as sweet as the box.

It now has its own narration here, read by Jane Doe.

Reddit

Where it first appeared · the original posting and its comments

Art

The story's artwork. Click a piece to open it at full size.
Candy Hearts — Cover
Cover1600 × 2400 (2:3)Ebook and PDF cover, Amazon listing, this pageCandy after candy
Candy Hearts — Banner
Banner2400 × 1000 (12:5)Story page header, home page cardAcross the hall
Candy Hearts — Video Still
Video Still1920 × 1080 (16:9)YouTube video background and title cardBe my Valentine?
Candy Hearts — YouTube Thumbnail
YouTube Thumbnail1280 × 720 (16:9)YouTube listing, video cards on the siteBe Mine? Kiss Me?
Candy Hearts — Share Card
Share Card1200 × 630 (1.91:1)Link previews on Facebook, X, Reddit, iMessageThe class walks past
Candy Hearts — Square
Square3000 × 3000 (1:1)Podcast and audio-drama art, Instagram, the Archive tileHow easily they're crushed

Titled versions: Cover · YouTube Thumbnail · Square

React

Curtain call

Tip jar

The stories are free. A coffee says thanks.
Buy me a coffee

Apple Pay via Ko-fi

More

Keep reading